All case studies

Do consistent local listings help customers find you?

Accurate listings let customers check your details and contact you wherever their search takes them.

Read the key findings

TL;DR

  • Think of listings as customer contact points. A 2024 search-results study found directories made up 31% of sampled top-ten organic results overall.

    Where listings appear in search
  • Keep name, address, phone and hours accurate. Consumers report checking directories for hours and say incorrect contact details can change what they do next.

    What consumers say they do
  • Judge listings by the customer actions they support. An older study counted mentions of businesses across sites and found more mentions among higher-ranked businesses. Track calls and visits from your own listings to see what they contribute.

    What the citation study can tell us
Share of sampled top-ten results for the two electrician search terms
  • “Electrician” · business websites59%
  • “Electrician” · directories35%
  • “Best electrician” · business websites24%
  • “Best electrician” · directories57%

In BrightLocal’s 2024 sample, the words customers used changed which kinds of sites featured most prominently.

See how it was measured

Be findable where customers search

A service business may appear in its own website, a map profile, trade directories and other local results. Accurate details help a customer recognise the business and take the next step, but the evidence on listings includes observation and surveys rather than a controlled test of NAP consistency.

Keep local visibility separate from customer action: a directory appearing in search is not the same as a call, and a survey response is not a measured ranking effect. The evidence below clarifies what is known and how to maintain listings responsibly.

Local search results analysis

Directories occupy a meaningful share of local results.

Directories accounted for 31% of the sampled top-ten organic results overall.

Share of sampled top-ten results for the two electrician search terms
  • “Electrician” · business websites59%
  • “Electrician” · directories35%
  • “Best electrician” · business websites24%
  • “Best electrician” · directories57%

BrightLocal analyzed 8,000 organic results for local searches. In the sampled results for “best electrician,” 57% were directory listings. For “electrician,” the directory share was 35%. The study counted search results at a point in time.

Try the searches a customer would use for your service. If a directory turns up repeatedly for those searches, check whether your entry is present, accurate and easy to act on.

BrightLocal, Business Listings Visibility Study, 2024. Read the Business Listings Visibility Study

US consumer survey

Customers use listings to check details before they act.

93% said they had used a business-information site to check opening hours in the previous year.

BrightLocal’s 2021 US survey of 1,141 consumers asked about directory use and reactions to incorrect listings. Responses were self-reported.

When contact information was wrong, 39% said they would switch to another business or abandon the search; 42% said they would call and 20% would check the address elsewhere. These percentages describe what respondents said they would do, not observed calls or lost sales.

Keep your business name, address where customers can visit, phone number and hours aligned across profiles. Service-area businesses should follow platform rules about displaying addresses and describe coverage clearly on their own site.

BrightLocal, Business Listings Trust Report 2021. Read the consumer listings survey

Observational rankings study

More citations and higher rankings moved together in one older study.

Position-one businesses averaged 86 citations; the study does not establish that citations caused those rankings.

BrightLocal compared citation counts with Google local rankings for the top ten results across 18,580 local keywords, 26 industries and 122,125 businesses in 2018. The study was observational.

Average citation counts tended to decline through the top ten positions, reaching 75 at position ten. This correlation cannot tell whether citations drove visibility, whether stronger businesses earned more citations, or whether other factors explain both. It measured counts, not NAP accuracy or consistency, and is now dated.

Prioritise accurate, useful listings over a race to accumulate citations. Monitor profile views, website visits, calls and qualified enquiries separately, and compare changes with the same local search area and time period.

BrightLocal, SEO Citations Study 2018. View the citations study

Keep listings useful and consistent.

Local profiles can be a customer’s first contact with your business. Maintain the facts, then measure profile actions and enquiries directly.

  1. Inventory your Google Business Profile and the directories customers use; remove duplicates and correct old details.
  2. Align business name, phone, hours and any public address with the website, following platform rules for service-area businesses.
  3. Track listing views, calls, website visits and qualified enquiries separately; do not infer a ranking gain from citation counts alone.

A listing earns its place when it helps a real customer verify and contact you.

Explore website sales optimisation